The Fort Worth Press - Huge Vietnam fraud case raises questions over banking system

USD -
AED 3.672498
AFN 64.494403
ALL 82.253977
AMD 360.50962
ANG 1.790403
AOA 917.502481
ARS 1552.246096
AUD 1.485112
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.702078
BAM 1.779545
BBD 2.01413
BDT 124.905034
BGN 1.77347
BHD 0.377203
BIF 3005
BMD 1
BND 1.288858
BOB 11.66537
BRL 5.777898
BSD 1.000059
BTN 93.425596
BWP 13.998644
BYN 3.001178
BYR 19600
BZD 2.011401
CAD 1.429395
CDF 2293.999606
CHF 0.839925
CLF 0.025261
CLP 994.199792
CNY 6.66615
CNH 6.66639
COP 3309.14
CRC 445.481718
CUC 1
CUP 24.000873
CVE 100.450399
CZK 22.134398
DJF 177.720413
DKK 6.79105
DOP 60.449654
DZD 137.026986
EGP 53.720699
ERN 15
ETB 164.140883
EUR 0.90863
FJD 2.297767
FKP 0.758367
GBP 0.757025
GEL 2.595028
GGP 0.758367
GHS 11.740303
GIP 0.758367
GMD 73.999853
GNF 8859.999559
GTQ 7.643069
GYD 209.144677
HKD 7.846185
HNL 26.886001
HRK 6.831965
HTG 131.024035
HUF 333.23026
IDR 18260
ILS 3.254645
IMP 0.758367
INR 93.44335
IQD 1516.079284
IRR 1929053.501903
ISK 124.288047
JEP 0.758367
JMD 158.919789
JOD 0.709015
JPY 159.346977
KES 130.040331
KGS 87.448989
KHR 4074.999997
KMF 448.000209
KPW 900.00035
KRW 1334.749919
KWD 0.31166
KYD 0.833458
KZT 444.016797
LAK 22537.499188
LBP 89550.000289
LKR 332.782835
LRD 168.750107
LSL 16.919297
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 6.462884
MAD 9.981438
MDL 18.311519
MGA 4549.44565
MKD 55.931125
MMK 2099.8229
MNT 3605.49036
MOP 8.082545
MRU 40.524838
MUR 47.859786
MVR 15.409659
MWK 1734.212921
MXN 18.428599
MYR 4.093697
MZN 63.902086
NAD 16.918528
NGN 1348.259779
NIO 36.80602
NOK 9.621275
NPR 149.481136
NZD 1.82025
OMR 0.384502
PAB 1.000032
PEN 3.415635
PGK 4.499381
PHP 63.619604
PKR 276.505202
PLN 3.99989
PYG 6230.864068
QAR 3.64562
RON 4.859598
RSD 106.886981
RUB 82.05005
RWF 1480.116648
SAR 3.756442
SBD 8.098361
SCR 13.913581
SDG 601.497935
SEK 10.1178
SGD 1.288285
SHP 0.758581
SLE 23.049753
SLL 20969.503664
SOS 571.501363
SRD 37.438005
STD 20697.981008
STN 22.292284
SVC 8.750364
SYP 13002.000337
SZL 16.918877
THB 33.789739
TJS 9.216015
TMT 3.51
TND 3.026264
TOP 2.40776
TRY 50.415055
TTD 6.771395
TWD 32.928797
TZS 2650.002987
UAH 45.33545
UGX 4149.985442
UYU 40.627659
UZS 12019.053598
VES 915.501901
VND 25712.5
VUV 120.845902
WST 2.802705
XAF 596.022501
XAG 0.021143
XAU 0.000259759826
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.802383
XDR 0.707052
XOF 596.022501
XPF 108.509428
YER 236.503848
ZAR 16.935602
ZMK 9001.196993
ZMW 20.486504
ZWL 321.999592
SSP 5946.953244
MXV 2.067401
  • RIO

    -0.3300

    97.04

    -0.34%

  • CMSC

    -0.0400

    20.67

    -0.19%

  • RELX

    0.0000

    33.41

    0%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    67.95

    0%

  • BCE

    -0.0700

    21.99

    -0.32%

  • BCC

    -0.0300

    75.66

    -0.04%

  • GSK

    0.8600

    51.08

    +1.68%

  • JRI

    -0.0300

    11.52

    -0.26%

  • NGG

    -0.1200

    76.68

    -0.16%

  • CMSD

    0.0900

    20.54

    +0.44%

  • BTI

    -0.0800

    55.75

    -0.14%

  • AZN

    2.0200

    168.1

    +1.2%

  • BP

    -1.4200

    43.16

    -3.29%

  • RYCEF

    0.4600

    19.7

    +2.34%

  • VOD

    0.0700

    17.02

    +0.41%

Huge Vietnam fraud case raises questions over banking system
Huge Vietnam fraud case raises questions over banking system / Photo: © AFP

Huge Vietnam fraud case raises questions over banking system

A multi-billion-dollar fraud scandal involving one of Vietnam's most prominent tycoons exposed systemic weaknesses in the country's banking sector, say analysts who warn other such cases could yet emerge.

Text size:

Judges on Tuesday upheld the death sentence of property developer Truong My Lan, who was convicted this year of embezzling vast sums from the Saigon Commercial Bank (SCB), which she controlled, having borrowed from tens of thousands of small investors.

Corruption is extensive in Vietnam, which ranked 83rd out of 180 in Transparency International's most recent Corruption Perception Index.

But the monumental scale of Lan's crime was unprecedented, with the $27 billion in losses prosecutors said she caused equivalent to Bosnia's entire annual gross domestic product.

Banking experts fear other damaging allegations are lurking in hidden recesses of the financial sector of the fast-growing economy, which is seen as a favoured destination for foreign investors looking for an alternative to China.

"SCB is not a single problem, it is an illness of the whole economy," banking expert Bui Kien Thanh told AFP.

The Vietnamese financial system was "characterised by a lack of tight state management", he said.

"Similar issues are rampant in society, so (Vietnam) needs to study and fix the problem before others arise."

Experts say a key systemic weakness is in the regulation of the corporate bond market, where companies borrow money from investors.

- Contemplating suicide -

In most developed markets, bonds are issued through independently regulated brokers on the basis of a full prospectus, graded by ratings agencies, and traded on stock exchanges.

But SCB, through its branches, misleadingly sold its bonds directly to retail customers, with staff trained for weeks on how to falsely reassure them their money was secure and the investment carried little risk.

Tens of thousands of people invested their savings in the bonds and lost everything when the bank collapsed and had to be bailed out by authorities, some of them contemplating suicide.

Most Vietnamese company debt is not rated for creditworthiness at all, with local ratings agency FiinRatings saying there were no corporate bonds with credit ratings in the country in the years before Lan's arrest.

That compared with an average of around 50 percent across the 10-member Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN).

According to state media, a judge at Lan's original trial asked police to look into the role played by staff at three of the world's biggest accounting firms that audited SCB's books -- Ernst & Young, Deloitte and KPMG.

None of the three responded to requests for comment by AFP.

At every level of the Vietnamese financial sector -- from employees on the ground to regulatory authorities -- there is a lack of training on financial markets, the risks involved and regulatory obligations, Thanh said.

On paper, Lan owned just five percent of shares in SCB, but at her trial, the court concluded that she effectively controlled more than 90 percent through family, friends and staff who were asked to hold stocks on her behalf.

- 'Can of worms' -

She then used her position to direct SCB management staff to withdraw money from the bank, over time transporting the equivalent of $4.4 billion in cash in trucks to her home and the offices of her Van Thinh Phat property firm.

"They don't question the paperwork... they just say, how are we going to do it? How fast can we do it?" said Khuong Huu Loc, an economist based in the United States.

"The whole system is a game based on collusion," he added. "The problem is, it gets so bad, (but) people let her continue on because you don't want to open the can of worms."

That comes on top of the corruption that is deeply embedded in the system -- one former chief inspector at the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) was found guilty of accepting a $5 million bribe to overlook financial problems at SCB.

Since the scandal emerged, Vietnam has stepped up an anti-corruption drive.

But Carl Thayer, an emeritus professor at The University of New South Wales, warned foreign investors were concerned anti-graft efforts had "led to a chilling effect on the state bureaucracy and a slowing of procedures", with officials fearing taking any decision could lead to their motives being questioned.

Even so, he said the revelations from the case meant Vietnam "will have to take exceptional steps to audit the banking system effectively".

Even if there was nothing on the gargantuan scale of SCB waiting to be found, Loc said that "there could be a smaller version out there".

"The question is how many?"

T.Dixon--TFWP