The Fort Worth Press - Proposed Fiscal Anchor Threatens South Africa’s Constitutional Rights Amid Health Crisis

USD -
AED 3.672503
AFN 63.999817
ALL 82.450149
AMD 357.809202
ANG 1.790403
AOA 917.499877
ARS 1549.874098
AUD 1.484483
AWG 1.8025
AZN 1.701804
BAM 1.7757
BBD 2.012982
BDT 124.44505
BGN 1.77347
BHD 0.377199
BIF 3005
BMD 1
BND 1.288366
BOB 11.659547
BRL 5.782163
BSD 0.99941
BTN 93.823002
BWP 13.990966
BYN 3.003223
BYR 19600
BZD 2.010077
CAD 1.429775
CDF 2318.000248
CHF 0.839835
CLF 0.025358
CLP 998.039782
CNY 6.66455
CNH 6.664155
COP 3318.97
CRC 445.37243
CUC 1
CUP 23.986201
CVE 100.374973
CZK 22.19355
DJF 177.719967
DKK 6.79487
DOP 60.550244
DZD 137.065944
EGP 53.6853
ERN 15
ETB 161.249886
EUR 0.90898
FJD 2.28475
FKP 0.756558
GBP 0.758315
GEL 2.594973
GGP 0.756558
GHS 11.734977
GIP 0.756558
GMD 73.500352
GNF 8859.999657
GTQ 7.63916
GYD 209.138162
HKD 7.84625
HNL 27.06947
HRK 6.831965
HTG 130.99394
HUF 330.970967
IDR 18279
ILS 3.24365
IMP 0.756558
INR 93.93975
IQD 1515
IRR 1925254.000425
ISK 124.339896
JEP 0.756558
JMD 158.482001
JOD 0.709041
JPY 159.416016
KES 130.039708
KGS 87.449402
KHR 4080.000054
KMF 447.50406
KPW 900.00035
KRW 1336.365011
KWD 0.31162
KYD 0.833012
KZT 444.73296
LAK 22524.999912
LBP 89550.0002
LKR 332.650884
LRD 168.501261
LSL 16.984982
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 6.455006
MAD 9.99725
MDL 18.281771
MGA 4594.000024
MKD 55.947457
MMK 2099.568705
MNT 3604.028735
MOP 8.07799
MRU 40.649826
MUR 47.819509
MVR 15.410198
MWK 1737.000365
MXN 18.52304
MYR 4.094017
MZN 63.910219
NAD 16.984964
NGN 1345.879753
NIO 36.750192
NOK 9.655665
NPR 150.11644
NZD 1.81763
OMR 0.384501
PAB 0.999532
PEN 3.408199
PGK 4.513966
PHP 63.918496
PKR 276.374515
PLN 4.001145
PYG 6202.732761
QAR 3.644022
RON 4.857802
RSD 106.930999
RUB 82.598883
RWF 1477
SAR 3.763042
SBD 8.098361
SCR 13.860567
SDG 601.548038
SEK 10.094865
SGD 1.288925
SHP 0.758581
SLE 23.04986
SLL 20969.503664
SOS 572.511276
SRD 37.453496
STD 20697.981008
STN 22.375
SVC 8.745744
SYP 13002.000337
SZL 16.984982
THB 33.885502
TJS 9.210795
TMT 3.51
TND 3.041994
TOP 2.40776
TRY 50.421202
TTD 6.787708
TWD 32.977904
TZS 2644.992965
UAH 45.435091
UGX 4147.791748
UYU 40.582868
UZS 12024.999857
VES 914.603597
VND 25764
VUV 120.719595
WST 2.810584
XAF 596.252115
XAG 0.021223
XAU 0.000259089508
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.801394
XDR 0.707052
XOF 596.252115
XPF 108.875027
YER 236.501049
ZAR 16.96925
ZMK 9001.199115
ZMW 20.4664
ZWL 321.999592
SSP 5945.381189
MXV 2.078532
  • RIO

    -0.3300

    97.04

    -0.34%

  • CMSC

    -0.0400

    20.67

    -0.19%

  • RELX

    0.0000

    33.41

    0%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    67.95

    0%

  • BCE

    -0.0700

    21.99

    -0.32%

  • BCC

    -0.0300

    75.66

    -0.04%

  • GSK

    0.8600

    51.08

    +1.68%

  • JRI

    -0.0300

    11.52

    -0.26%

  • NGG

    -0.1200

    76.68

    -0.16%

  • CMSD

    0.0900

    20.54

    +0.44%

  • BTI

    -0.0800

    55.75

    -0.14%

  • AZN

    2.0200

    168.1

    +1.2%

  • BP

    -1.4200

    43.16

    -3.29%

  • RYCEF

    0.4600

    19.7

    +2.34%

  • VOD

    0.0700

    17.02

    +0.41%

Proposed Fiscal Anchor Threatens South Africa’s Constitutional Rights Amid Health Crisis
Proposed Fiscal Anchor Threatens South Africa’s Constitutional Rights Amid Health Crisis

Proposed Fiscal Anchor Threatens South Africa’s Constitutional Rights Amid Health Crisis

As Gauteng loses 100 nurses monthly and public health facilities face worsening shortages, proposals to legally bind South Africa to a fiscal anchor are drawing sharp criticism. Experts argue that such measures threaten to entrench austerity, directly undermining constitutional rights by restricting spending on essential social services.

Text size:

Gauteng province is losing approximately 100 nurses every month, a statistic that underscores the deepening crisis in public healthcare as South Africa considers legally binding fiscal anchors. While the Minister of Finance announced in February that R21.3 billion and R9.9 billion were added to health and education budgets over the medium term—increases pitched deliberately above Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation to defend frontline posts—a recent report reveals that critical positions remain vulnerable to Treasury’s debt-reduction strategies.

The proposed fiscal anchor, which would cap state borrowing and spending within a specific range by establishing a binding debt or primary budget surplus target, has drawn criticism for potentially writing austerity into law. Critics argue that this approach forces public spending, including health worker salaries, to compete for an increasingly tight budget, thereby threatening the stability of frontline services.

The Human Resources for Health (HRH) Strategy projects that South Africa will face a shortage of approximately 97,000 healthcare workers across all categories by 2030. The HRH warns that this shortfall will worsen if health workforce expenditure increases only in line with inflation, a constraint that becomes more acute with the introduction of a legal fiscal anchor. The strategy aims to address inequities across provinces, but current trends suggest that population growth alone will outpace available resources without significant intervention.

Efforts to reduce the public sector wage bill have included offering early retirement packages to civil servants. The stated objective is to replace older, more expensive workers with younger staff; however, data indicates that these positions are often not refilled. Aliya Chikte, a researcher at the Alternative Information and Development Centre (AIDC) and Deputy Chairperson of the Budget Justice Coalition (BJC), notes that voluntary packages tend to attract experienced nurses, doctors, teachers, and specialists—workers the state can least afford to lose. Consequently, the strategy reflects a headcount-reduction exercise rather than generational renewal.

The nursing crisis in Gauteng is part of a broader public sector contraction. According to Gauteng’s Estimates of Provincial Revenue and Expenditure (EPRE), the province reduced its medical and related personnel by 2,899 between the 2024/25 and 2025/26 financial years. An analysis of budget data further shows that the majority of provinces have fewer nurses than they did three years ago.

This reduction in workforce coincides with Treasury’s assertion that the country has maintained a primary budget surplus for three consecutive years. A primary budget surplus occurs when government revenue exceeds expenditure on all items except interest payments on loans. Duncan Pieterse, the Director-General of Treasury, highlighted this trend, yet critics point out that the growing surplus has occurred alongside severe worker shortages in schools, hospitals, and clinics.

The Minister of Health previously indicated in a parliamentary reply that South Africa has only four doctors for every 10,000 people, less than half of the desired international benchmark of 10. Chikte argues that when the Minister describes budget increases as "lifelines," it merely signifies that departments are drowning at a slower pace rather than recovering.

The debate over fiscal policy extends to the reliability of debt metrics. The Minister of Finance has admitted that austerity can be self-defeating and acknowledged Treasury’s position that debt as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is an unreliable indicator because it depends heavily on the GDP denominator. During economic shocks, when GDP falls, the debt-to-GDP ratio can worsen even if the primary budget surplus grows.

With economic growth stagnating and population needs increasing, there are concerns that a binding fiscal anchor will be incompatible with improved socioeconomic outcomes. Parliament’s Standing Committee on Finance recommended in its March 2024 report to National Treasury that "the binding fiscal anchor should not be the trajectory of fiscal policy in relation to public expenditure as they limit fiscal policy parameters and narrow the NT’s fiscal policy orientation."

Chikte emphasizes that the focus should shift to why South Africa pays high interest on its debt and how to ensure debt-service costs do not compete exorbitantly with social and economic development spending. Debt-service costs as a percentage of expenditure are projected to rise from 15% in 2022/23 to 18% in 2028/29.

Research by AIDC, including the South African Fair Tax Monitor and studies on the Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF), suggests that progressive funding mechanisms remain available. These resources could help stop the erosion of constitutional rights and reduce the cost of servicing debt without shrinking the state. Chikte warns that South Africa, described as the world’s most unequal country, cannot afford to shrink its public sector further.

The context for these fiscal debates includes recent monetary policy adjustments. At last year’s Medium Term Budget Policy Statement (MTBPS), the inflation target was lowered. However, subsequent events, including the war between the US and Israel on Iran and the Reserve Bank’s response, demonstrated the limitations of tighter targets against inflation driven by external shocks. As this year’s MTBPS approaches, critics urge policymakers to avoid locking in reforms that could squeeze an already struggling economy.

L.Rodriguez--TFWP