RIO
-0.3300
Local marijuana decriminalization efforts in Texas confront a complex legal landscape following recent elections. While new Democratic leadership, including Attorney General Nathan Johnson, signals potential policy shifts, existing state statutes and a Republican-controlled Supreme Court continue to pose significant barriers to implementing voter-approved measures like Dallas’s Proposition R.
Local initiatives to decriminalize low-level marijuana possession in Texas face a complex and uncertain future, even as the state’s political landscape shifts toward Democratic control. The outcome of these efforts hinges on the discretion of newly elected Attorney General Nathan Johnson, ongoing litigation, and the enduring authority of the Republican-controlled Texas Supreme Court.
In 2024, Dallas voters approved Proposition R, formally known as the Dallas Freedom Act, which decriminalized possession of less than four ounces of marijuana and eliminated the odor of cannabis as probable cause for searches. The measure also stripped governmental immunity and mandated specific police funding targets. Although a majority of the Dallas City Council voted to implement the ordinance and interim Police Chief Michael Igo issued a memo cementing the departmental shift, the policy’s lifespan was brief.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, a Republican, filed a lawsuit challenging Proposition R less than a week after the Dallas Police Department updated its policies. This legal action followed a pattern established by Paxton’s office, which contested similar decriminalization measures in Austin, San Marcos, Killeen, Denton, and Elgin after voters approved them in 2022. Courts have blocked the measures in Austin and San Marcos on the grounds that cities cannot preempt state law, while Denton and Elgin voluntarily voided their ordinances to avoid further legal costs.
In Dallas, the city reached a settlement with the state in July 2025. The agreement included a joint petition for a temporary injunction blocking the implementation of Proposition R. Consequently, less than a year after 67% of voters approved the measure, it was effectively neutralized. Representatives for the City of Dallas and the Dallas Police Department declined to comment on the matter, citing their policy of not discussing ongoing litigation.
The political context for these legal battles has changed significantly following the recent election cycle. Ken Paxton lost his re-election bid to Democrat James Talarico in a decisive Senate race. Additionally, Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick became the first 21st-century Republican lieutenant governor to lose his seat, defeated by Vikki Goodwin. Gina Hinojosa is set to become the state’s first Democratic governor since 1994. Across the ticket, Republicans lost ground to Democrats, a group that has largely signaled support for a more progressive approach to marijuana policy.
Nathan Johnson, a Dallas-area Democrat and former state senator who defeated Republican Mayes Middleton, will assume the role of attorney general. His victory has led to speculation that he may catalyze a less restrictive enforcement environment statewide. Furthermore, the 15th Court of Appeals, which previously ruled against Austin and San Marcos, is now controlled exclusively by Democratic judges after they won all three seats in the midterm election.
However, significant legal obstacles remain. The state statutes that define marijuana possession as a crime are still in effect, creating boundaries for even progressive judges. Moreover, Republicans retain control of the Texas Supreme Court with a 5-4 majority. This court serves as the final decision-maker for most constitutional questions in the state and has the power to overrule lower appellate courts.
The question of whether Dallas residents can carry small amounts of marijuana without legal repercussions remains unpredictable, closely tied to the upcoming legislative session. During his time as a state senator, Johnson filed bills aimed at rolling back prohibitive measures. In the 2025 special session, he sought to create a less restrictive regulatory framework for the hemp industry and introduced companion legislation to decriminalize low-level marijuana possession.
In a release regarding the bill, Johnson stated that marijuana possession accounts for over 30% of drug-related arrests in the state. He argued that these arrests divert law enforcement resources away from violent crime, damage families and communities, and impose unnecessary costs on taxpayers. Although both bills were rejected by the Republican majority, they provide insight into Johnson’s potential priorities as attorney general.
Katharine Neill Harris, a drug policy fellow at Rice University, noted that while Johnson has the power to drop suits against decriminalization or refuse to pursue further state challenges to hemp industry cases, the approach is not without risk. "The prosecutor in [those cases] is the attorney general’s office," Harris said. "Nathan Johnson could choose to stop pursuing them. In which case, you know, in theory, the cities could then implement the ordinances as voters approve."
Harris cautioned that this strategy is not foolproof. Other law enforcement officials could file lawsuits challenging these decisions, potentially reaching the Republican-controlled State Supreme Court. For instance, after Killeen voters passed a decriminalization proposition in 2022, county commissioners filed a lawsuit that remains ongoing.
In Dallas, Proposition R included a provision stating that if decriminalization is blocked by state courts, enforcement of marijuana charges would become the lowest priority for the police. This deprioritization clause was designed to maintain some level of policy influence even if full decriminalization was legally barred. Houston voters approved a similar proposition in November, crafting it specifically to avoid the decriminalization language that exposed other municipalities to legal battles.
Harris explained that while Houston’s measure is not an official prohibition on enforcement, it directs police to prioritize marijuana cases last, a provision she understands remains legal in the state. However, Dallas’s deprioritization clause is currently blocked under the 2025 settlement agreement with Paxton’s office. The injunction prevents the city from enforcing any part of Proposition R, including the low-priority enforcement section.
Dallas officials may challenge this injunction, and Johnson retains broad discretion over which cases his office will contest. Nevertheless, the long-term outlook for decriminalization remains ambiguous. All legal paths ultimately lead back to the Supreme Court, where conservative judges hold a majority. Conservative local officials retain the ability to file cases even if Johnson chooses not to pursue them.
Despite these hurdles, pro-marijuana advocates have expressed optimism regarding the upcoming legislative session beginning in January. With Democrats now controlling the Texas House, lawmakers have filed bills to expand the state’s medical marijuana program, decrease penalties for THC concentrates, and potentially legalize a commercial marijuana industry.
Harris identified the Texas Legislature as the most viable avenue for comprehensive reform in the immediate term. She noted that while decriminalization may not generate the same public attention as outright legalization, it plays a critical role in reducing the impact of low-level offenders on the justice system. "It’s a quieter policy, but it is a really important one because it addresses and removes those legal system harms that are associated with use," Harris said.
Research supports the efficacy of decriminalization in reducing arrests, particularly among youth. Studies comparing states that decriminalize versus those that legalize show that while adult arrests decline under both policies, youth arrests see a more significant drop with decriminalization alone.
The racial disparities in enforcement were a primary driver for Proposition R in Dallas. According to reporting by The Dallas Morning News, 80% of the 357 people arrested for possession between June 2024 and June 2025 were Black. Despite making up less than a quarter of the county population, Black residents have historically represented the majority of arrests for less than four ounces of marijuana.
Harris suggested that if legalization fails to gain bipartisan support, decriminalization could serve as a compromise measure. It would allow Democrats to achieve policy wins while reducing the damaging effects of enforcement targeting small amounts of cannabis. "It would be good to have that more modest decriminalization in place, so that we’re not still subjecting Texans to these legal system risks when we know that marijuana use is so prevalent," Harris said. "And then also that sort of removes the issues regarding these local ordinances."
As the new administration takes office, the tension between voter-approved local measures and state-level prohibition will continue to define Texas’s marijuana policy landscape. The decisions made by Attorney General Johnson and the legislature in the coming months will determine whether decriminalization can survive the current legal framework or if it will remain suspended pending further judicial review.
W.Lane--TFWP