The Fort Worth Press - Young plaintiffs stand tall after taking on Trump climate agenda in court

USD -
AED 3.672504
AFN 63.000368
ALL 82.776172
AMD 376.396497
ANG 1.790083
AOA 917.000367
ARS 1391.503978
AUD 1.422273
AWG 1.8025
AZN 1.70397
BAM 1.687271
BBD 2.010611
BDT 122.494932
BGN 1.709309
BHD 0.377087
BIF 2954.923867
BMD 1
BND 1.276711
BOB 6.898158
BRL 5.313404
BSD 0.998318
BTN 93.32787
BWP 13.612561
BYN 3.028771
BYR 19600
BZD 2.007764
CAD 1.37265
CDF 2275.000362
CHF 0.78844
CLF 0.023504
CLP 928.050396
CNY 6.886404
CNH 6.906095
COP 3669.412932
CRC 466.289954
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 95.125739
CZK 21.149204
DJF 177.768192
DKK 6.457504
DOP 59.25894
DZD 132.24804
EGP 51.758616
ERN 15
ETB 157.330889
EUR 0.862704
FJD 2.21445
FKP 0.75164
GBP 0.749681
GEL 2.71504
GGP 0.75164
GHS 10.882112
GIP 0.75164
GMD 73.503851
GNF 8750.377432
GTQ 7.646983
GYD 208.85994
HKD 7.83525
HNL 26.423673
HRK 6.511304
HTG 130.966657
HUF 339.680388
IDR 16956.2
ILS 3.109125
IMP 0.75164
INR 94.01055
IQD 1307.768624
IRR 1315625.000352
ISK 124.270386
JEP 0.75164
JMD 156.839063
JOD 0.70904
JPY 159.240385
KES 129.327524
KGS 87.447904
KHR 3989.129966
KMF 427.00035
KPW 899.870128
KRW 1505.310383
KWD 0.30657
KYD 0.831903
KZT 479.946513
LAK 21437.260061
LBP 89404.995039
LKR 311.417849
LRD 182.685589
LSL 16.84053
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 6.39089
MAD 9.328473
MDL 17.385153
MGA 4162.53289
MKD 53.176897
MMK 2099.940821
MNT 3585.542519
MOP 8.05806
MRU 39.961178
MUR 46.510378
MVR 15.460378
MWK 1731.096062
MXN 17.898204
MYR 3.939039
MZN 63.903729
NAD 16.84053
NGN 1356.250377
NIO 36.733814
NOK 9.569995
NPR 149.324936
NZD 1.712622
OMR 0.384504
PAB 0.998318
PEN 3.451408
PGK 4.309192
PHP 60.150375
PKR 278.721304
PLN 3.69475
PYG 6520.295044
QAR 3.65052
RON 4.401504
RSD 101.324246
RUB 82.822413
RWF 1452.529871
SAR 3.754657
SBD 8.05166
SCR 13.69771
SDG 601.000339
SEK 9.344038
SGD 1.282504
SHP 0.750259
SLE 24.575038
SLL 20969.510825
SOS 570.504249
SRD 37.487504
STD 20697.981008
STN 21.136177
SVC 8.734849
SYP 110.536894
SZL 16.845965
THB 32.908038
TJS 9.588492
TMT 3.51
TND 2.948367
TOP 2.40776
TRY 44.252504
TTD 6.773066
TWD 32.036704
TZS 2595.522581
UAH 43.73308
UGX 3773.454687
UYU 40.227753
UZS 12170.987361
VES 454.69063
VND 26312
VUV 119.352434
WST 2.727514
XAF 565.894837
XAG 0.014693
XAU 0.000222
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.799163
XDR 0.703792
XOF 565.894837
XPF 102.885735
YER 238.603589
ZAR 17.12748
ZMK 9001.203584
ZMW 19.491869
ZWL 321.999592
  • BCE

    0.0600

    25.79

    +0.23%

  • RIO

    -2.5000

    83.15

    -3.01%

  • NGG

    -3.5400

    81.99

    -4.32%

  • CMSC

    -0.2000

    22.65

    -0.88%

  • RBGPF

    -13.5000

    69

    -19.57%

  • BCC

    -1.5600

    68.3

    -2.28%

  • GSK

    -0.5300

    51.84

    -1.02%

  • CMSD

    -0.2420

    22.658

    -1.07%

  • BTI

    -1.3500

    57.37

    -2.35%

  • VOD

    -0.0900

    14.33

    -0.63%

  • AZN

    -5.3300

    183.6

    -2.9%

  • RELX

    -0.4600

    33.36

    -1.38%

  • RYCEF

    -1.2600

    15.34

    -8.21%

  • BP

    -1.0800

    44.78

    -2.41%

  • JRI

    -0.3900

    11.77

    -3.31%

Young plaintiffs stand tall after taking on Trump climate agenda in court
Young plaintiffs stand tall after taking on Trump climate agenda in court / Photo: © AFP

Young plaintiffs stand tall after taking on Trump climate agenda in court

Young Americans challenging President Donald Trump’s fossil fuel agenda say they were proud to have their day in court -- even if it meant fielding tough, sometimes perplexing questions from government lawyers.

Text size:

"I don't think the gravity of that situation has permeated through my brain yet," 19-year-old Joseph Lee told AFP at the close of a two-day hearing in Lighthiser v. Trump.

"I'm going to wake up and realize, 'Wow, I really did that.' I testified in court against my own federal government, and it's just such a meaningful thing to be part of this process."

The case challenges three executive orders that the plaintiffs say trample their inalienable rights to life and liberty by seeking to "unleash" fossil fuels while sidelining sources of renewable energy.

The plaintiffs also seek to reverse the administration's dismantling of climate science -- from suppressing a key national climate report to proposing to shut down a critical carbon dioxide monitoring site in Hawaii.

Judge Dana Christensen is now weighing whether to grant a preliminary injunction that could pave the way to trial -- or throw the case out, as the government has urged.

- 'It's not about ACs' -

Despite the gravity of the issues at the center of the case, the plaintiffs said they found themselves questioning the seemingly insignificant details raised in court.

Lee, from California, testified that a case of heat stroke left him hospitalized on the brink of organ failure.

During cross-examination, Justice Department attorney Erik Van Der Stouwe asked whether he had sued the University of California, San Diego over its lack of air conditioning in dorms, implying that -- and not climate change -- was the remedy.

"It's not about ACs," Lee later told AFP.

"Minimizing it to something as trivial just goes to show" that the government's case lacks merit, he added.

At another point, Van Der Stouwe questioned whether Lee could prove Trump's climate cuts cost him opportunities to gain a research position at university -- even though a university-wide letter, entered into evidence, explicitly cited the executive actions for reducing such positions.

When pressed on how he could be certain, Lee replied that as a student he lacked the power to investigate the matter beyond all doubt.

"But you did have the capacity to investigate the government's executive orders?" the lawyer shot back.

Lee responded he had the ability to read their plain language -- a remark that drew murmurs of approval from the packed and supportive courtroom.

- 'Really empowering' -

In another strange exchange, 20-year-old Avery McRae of Oregon was asked whether the anxiety she linked to climate change might stem from having spent half her life suing the federal government -- or from how her family's horses affect the environment.

And when 17-year-old Jorja McCormick took the stand, she recalled the day a firefighter knocked on her family's door and ordered them to evacuate as flames closed in, a moment, she said, that left her traumatized and that harmed her family's health.

Under cross examination, government attorney Miranda Jensen asked: "You just testified you have three horses, right? You're aware that raising horses contributes to global warming?"

Speaking after the hearings wrapped up, McCormick said she had mulled over the exchange.

"There's coal trains going through my downtown every day," spewing toxic dust, she told AFP.

"So I think my horses being out on open property minding their own business compared to coal trains hurting the entire community is quite different."

Despite the grilling, McCormick described testifying as cathartic.

"Being on the stand was really empowering -- telling my story, getting it out into the world like that was almost healing."

Whatever the outcome of Lighthiser v. Trump, she said she plans to continue her activism.

"A better future is possible," added Lee. "If a decision isn't favorable, we'll keep fighting."

S.Palmer--TFWP