The Fort Worth Press - Young plaintiffs stand tall after taking on Trump climate agenda in court

USD -
AED 3.6725
AFN 66.000063
ALL 82.019444
AMD 379.030024
ANG 1.79008
AOA 917.000222
ARS 1452.1415
AUD 1.436864
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.699581
BAM 1.650151
BBD 2.016242
BDT 122.43245
BGN 1.67937
BHD 0.377035
BIF 2964.5
BMD 1
BND 1.271584
BOB 6.942435
BRL 5.261799
BSD 1.001076
BTN 91.544186
BWP 13.176113
BYN 2.86646
BYR 19600
BZD 2.013297
CAD 1.36714
CDF 2154.999935
CHF 0.778795
CLF 0.021919
CLP 865.500352
CNY 6.946501
CNH 6.938895
COP 3622.05
CRC 496.70313
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 93.874975
CZK 20.59725
DJF 177.719709
DKK 6.327105
DOP 62.950149
DZD 129.934449
EGP 47.089896
ERN 15
ETB 155.250273
EUR 0.84721
FJD 2.206598
FKP 0.729754
GBP 0.731315
GEL 2.694994
GGP 0.729754
GHS 10.954985
GIP 0.729754
GMD 73.55548
GNF 8751.000245
GTQ 7.681242
GYD 209.445862
HKD 7.810703
HNL 26.449908
HRK 6.386897
HTG 131.200378
HUF 322.735497
IDR 16766.2
ILS 3.10084
IMP 0.729754
INR 90.46795
IQD 1310.5
IRR 42125.000158
ISK 123.039932
JEP 0.729754
JMD 157.178897
JOD 0.709014
JPY 155.4575
KES 129.13006
KGS 87.449831
KHR 4025.492445
KMF 418.000086
KPW 900
KRW 1450.029709
KWD 0.30714
KYD 0.834223
KZT 505.528533
LAK 21494.999879
LBP 85549.999924
LKR 310.004134
LRD 185.999884
LSL 16.110186
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 6.320108
MAD 9.15875
MDL 16.948552
MGA 4450.000276
MKD 52.248327
MMK 2099.986463
MNT 3564.625242
MOP 8.053239
MRU 39.929374
MUR 45.650252
MVR 15.450036
MWK 1737.000377
MXN 17.388398
MYR 3.958498
MZN 63.749877
NAD 16.109867
NGN 1391.000271
NIO 36.697378
NOK 9.69397
NPR 146.471315
NZD 1.662775
OMR 0.38451
PAB 1.00108
PEN 3.365975
PGK 4.237972
PHP 58.919935
PKR 279.749793
PLN 3.57693
PYG 6656.120146
QAR 3.64125
RON 4.317897
RSD 99.493038
RUB 76.448038
RWF 1453
SAR 3.750185
SBD 8.058101
SCR 14.250149
SDG 601.501494
SEK 8.95644
SGD 1.271315
SHP 0.750259
SLE 24.474994
SLL 20969.499267
SOS 571.503458
SRD 38.025022
STD 20697.981008
STN 21.25
SVC 8.759629
SYP 11059.574895
SZL 16.109942
THB 31.490262
TJS 9.349825
TMT 3.51
TND 2.847497
TOP 2.40776
TRY 43.480099
TTD 6.777673
TWD 31.591702
TZS 2588.490529
UAH 43.112529
UGX 3575.692379
UYU 38.836508
UZS 12249.999719
VES 369.791581
VND 26020
VUV 119.156711
WST 2.710781
XAF 553.468475
XAG 0.012114
XAU 0.000209
XCD 2.70255
XCG 1.80413
XDR 0.687215
XOF 551.505966
XPF 101.749394
YER 238.374969
ZAR 16.066915
ZMK 9001.197925
ZMW 19.646044
ZWL 321.999592
  • RBGPF

    0.1000

    82.5

    +0.12%

  • SCS

    0.0200

    16.14

    +0.12%

  • RELX

    -0.2700

    35.53

    -0.76%

  • RYCEF

    0.7000

    16.7

    +4.19%

  • BTI

    0.3100

    60.99

    +0.51%

  • NGG

    -0.6600

    84.61

    -0.78%

  • CMSC

    -0.0100

    23.75

    -0.04%

  • AZN

    1.3100

    188.41

    +0.7%

  • GSK

    0.8700

    52.47

    +1.66%

  • BP

    -0.1800

    37.7

    -0.48%

  • BCE

    -0.0300

    25.83

    -0.12%

  • RIO

    1.4900

    92.52

    +1.61%

  • CMSD

    0.0300

    24.08

    +0.12%

  • BCC

    0.9400

    81.75

    +1.15%

  • JRI

    0.0700

    13.15

    +0.53%

  • VOD

    0.2600

    14.91

    +1.74%

Young plaintiffs stand tall after taking on Trump climate agenda in court
Young plaintiffs stand tall after taking on Trump climate agenda in court / Photo: © AFP

Young plaintiffs stand tall after taking on Trump climate agenda in court

Young Americans challenging President Donald Trump’s fossil fuel agenda say they were proud to have their day in court -- even if it meant fielding tough, sometimes perplexing questions from government lawyers.

Text size:

"I don't think the gravity of that situation has permeated through my brain yet," 19-year-old Joseph Lee told AFP at the close of a two-day hearing in Lighthiser v. Trump.

"I'm going to wake up and realize, 'Wow, I really did that.' I testified in court against my own federal government, and it's just such a meaningful thing to be part of this process."

The case challenges three executive orders that the plaintiffs say trample their inalienable rights to life and liberty by seeking to "unleash" fossil fuels while sidelining sources of renewable energy.

The plaintiffs also seek to reverse the administration's dismantling of climate science -- from suppressing a key national climate report to proposing to shut down a critical carbon dioxide monitoring site in Hawaii.

Judge Dana Christensen is now weighing whether to grant a preliminary injunction that could pave the way to trial -- or throw the case out, as the government has urged.

- 'It's not about ACs' -

Despite the gravity of the issues at the center of the case, the plaintiffs said they found themselves questioning the seemingly insignificant details raised in court.

Lee, from California, testified that a case of heat stroke left him hospitalized on the brink of organ failure.

During cross-examination, Justice Department attorney Erik Van Der Stouwe asked whether he had sued the University of California, San Diego over its lack of air conditioning in dorms, implying that -- and not climate change -- was the remedy.

"It's not about ACs," Lee later told AFP.

"Minimizing it to something as trivial just goes to show" that the government's case lacks merit, he added.

At another point, Van Der Stouwe questioned whether Lee could prove Trump's climate cuts cost him opportunities to gain a research position at university -- even though a university-wide letter, entered into evidence, explicitly cited the executive actions for reducing such positions.

When pressed on how he could be certain, Lee replied that as a student he lacked the power to investigate the matter beyond all doubt.

"But you did have the capacity to investigate the government's executive orders?" the lawyer shot back.

Lee responded he had the ability to read their plain language -- a remark that drew murmurs of approval from the packed and supportive courtroom.

- 'Really empowering' -

In another strange exchange, 20-year-old Avery McRae of Oregon was asked whether the anxiety she linked to climate change might stem from having spent half her life suing the federal government -- or from how her family's horses affect the environment.

And when 17-year-old Jorja McCormick took the stand, she recalled the day a firefighter knocked on her family's door and ordered them to evacuate as flames closed in, a moment, she said, that left her traumatized and that harmed her family's health.

Under cross examination, government attorney Miranda Jensen asked: "You just testified you have three horses, right? You're aware that raising horses contributes to global warming?"

Speaking after the hearings wrapped up, McCormick said she had mulled over the exchange.

"There's coal trains going through my downtown every day," spewing toxic dust, she told AFP.

"So I think my horses being out on open property minding their own business compared to coal trains hurting the entire community is quite different."

Despite the grilling, McCormick described testifying as cathartic.

"Being on the stand was really empowering -- telling my story, getting it out into the world like that was almost healing."

Whatever the outcome of Lighthiser v. Trump, she said she plans to continue her activism.

"A better future is possible," added Lee. "If a decision isn't favorable, we'll keep fighting."

S.Palmer--TFWP