The Fort Worth Press - There will be accountability for Ukraine crimes, eventually: expert

USD -
AED 3.67295
AFN 72.503991
ALL 95.850403
AMD 406.095122
ANG 1.802595
AOA 831.503981
ARS 837.498454
AUD 1.525553
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.70397
BAM 1.806769
BBD 2.019548
BDT 109.776714
BGN 1.80721
BHD 0.376764
BIF 2866
BMD 1
BND 1.344887
BOB 6.91095
BRL 4.995504
BSD 1.000212
BTN 83.134148
BWP 13.805463
BYN 3.273255
BYR 19600
BZD 2.01613
CAD 1.34865
CDF 2765.000362
CHF 0.88059
CLF 0.035523
CLP 980.203912
CNY 7.195404
COP 3963.32
CRC 514.644409
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 102.250394
CZK 23.428104
DJF 177.720394
DKK 6.88885
DOP 58.803886
DZD 134.497417
EGP 30.846676
ERN 15
ETB 56.690392
EUR 0.92305
FJD 2.235204
FKP 0.788863
GBP 0.788706
GEL 2.650391
GGP 0.788863
GHS 12.37504
GIP 0.788863
GMD 67.27504
GNF 8595.000355
GTQ 7.816202
GYD 209.259251
HKD 7.82205
HNL 24.82504
HRK 7.030095
HTG 132.650327
HUF 359.530388
IDR 15594.15
ILS 3.63115
IMP 0.788863
INR 82.88205
IQD 1310
IRR 42032.503818
ISK 137.803816
JEP 0.788863
JMD 156.438516
JOD 0.70904
JPY 150.48504
KES 146.000351
KGS 89.430385
KHR 4080.000351
KMF 454.950384
KPW 899.999196
KRW 1331.00035
KWD 0.307804
KYD 0.833557
KZT 451.10719
LAK 20890.000349
LBP 89650.000349
LKR 310.983214
LRD 190.650382
LSL 19.190382
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.840381
MAD 10.056504
MDL 17.908628
MGA 4535.000347
MKD 56.924576
MMK 2100.406003
MNT 3406.327173
MOP 8.059806
MRU 39.750379
MUR 45.622141
MVR 15.403741
MWK 1683.000345
MXN 17.116204
MYR 4.777504
MZN 63.503732
NAD 19.190377
NGN 1607.000344
NIO 36.825039
NOK 10.600505
NPR 133.014933
NZD 1.613684
OMR 0.384952
PAB 1.000212
PEN 3.811504
PGK 3.725039
PHP 55.935039
PKR 279.725038
PLN 3.979231
PYG 7281.326935
QAR 3.640504
RON 4.597904
RSD 108.338038
RUB 93.055038
RWF 1275
SAR 3.750554
SBD 8.500465
SCR 13.493038
SDG 601.00034
SEK 10.292915
SGD 1.343038
SHP 1.26625
SLE 22.483622
SLL 19750.000338
SOS 571.503664
SRD 35.701038
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.752206
SYP 13001.869854
SZL 19.19037
THB 35.930369
TJS 10.952207
TMT 3.51
TND 3.123504
TOP 2.360304
TRY 30.818685
TTD 6.798372
TWD 31.617038
TZS 2550.000335
UAH 38.283133
UGX 3935.443938
UYU 39.122944
UZS 12537.503622
VEF 3618584.714698
VES 36.186223
VND 24640
VUV 120.023184
WST 2.739916
XAF 605.98169
XAG 0.043588
XAU 0.000491
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.755032
XOF 604.503597
XPF 110.380364
YER 250.350363
ZAR 19.25804
ZMK 9001.203589
ZMW 22.979533
ZWL 321.999592
  • RELX

    0.0900

    44.44

    +0.2%

  • GSK

    0.0600

    42.22

    +0.14%

  • SCS

    0.1000

    12.8

    +0.78%

  • CMSC

    0.0200

    24.8

    +0.08%

  • BP

    -0.1100

    35.38

    -0.31%

  • SLAC

    -0.0050

    10.305

    -0.05%

  • BTI

    0.0300

    30.5

    +0.1%

  • NGG

    0.6100

    66.64

    +0.92%

  • RBGPF

    0.3360

    72.822

    +0.46%

  • AZN

    1.7000

    65.83

    +2.58%

  • RIO

    0.2900

    65.98

    +0.44%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0300

    4.45

    -0.67%

  • VOD

    0.0700

    8.47

    +0.83%

  • CMSD

    0.0500

    24.81

    +0.2%

  • BCE

    -0.0100

    37.6

    -0.03%

  • BCC

    2.8800

    129.42

    +2.23%

  • JRI

    0.0425

    11.53

    +0.37%

There will be accountability for Ukraine crimes, eventually: expert
There will be accountability for Ukraine crimes, eventually: expert

There will be accountability for Ukraine crimes, eventually: expert

Shocking images of bodies strewn in Ukrainian streets clearly indicate war crimes, but legally proving that and ensuring accountability is tricky, according to a top international justice expert.

Text size:

The calls for war crimes investigations and trials over Moscow's conflict in Ukraine have intensified after horrific photographs emerged of corpses in roads and in mass graves in Bucha, near Kyiv, after Russian troops retreated from the devastated town.

The Kremlin has denied responsibility and suggested the images are fake or that the deaths occurred after Russian forces pulled out of the area.

Philip Grant, who heads the TRIAL International NGO that works to ensure accountability for international crimes, said that, while powerful, such images alone cannot legally prove war crimes have occurred and who is responsible.

"Images in themselves rarely count as the defining evidence," he told AFP in an interview.

"They can reveal important elements, but they will not reveal the full story," he said.

Grant said it was important to be "cautious" when interpreting events, pointing to past examples of manipulation and misinterpretation.

There was, for instance, the dramatic misreporting that a massacre occurred during the 1989 Timisoara uprising in Romania, and Soviet efforts during the Nuremberg trials to pin its own 1940 Katyn massacre of Polish officers on Nazi Germany.

- 'Clear-cut' -

At the same time, Grant said, investigators should "exercise sound judgement" with what they can see.

In the case of the Bucha images, "it looks pretty clear-cut that war crimes have been committed," he said.

But the images alone do not make it possible to "attribute that responsibility to a specific person or to a specific group."

Even if it was determined that "Russians did it," he said, "that's not accountability. We need to know who ordered that."

"Is it (Russian President) Vladimir Putin? Is it the commander on the ground? Is it a rogue unit?"

"In terms of criminal liability," he said, "it's too early to say who should end up in court for those crimes."

That process can be long and complicated, he acknowledged.

As the International Criminal Court, the UN Human Rights Council and a growing number of countries begin sending war crimes investigators to Ukraine, they will have their work cut out for them, Grant said.

- Is it a crime? -

The first step is to "make sure you have a crime".

"It might look obvious, but it's not always," he said, pointing out that in war, unlike in civilian life, killing people can be lawful.

A soldier killed in battle is not considered a crime, but if that soldier is killed after being wounded or taken prisoner, it is.

And if you find a mass grave with soldiers killed in combat, "that is not a crime," Grant said.

But "if you find in the mass grave a family, civilians, that is probably a crime."

After determining a crime has been committed comes the even more complicated task of figuring out who is legally responsible.

With war crimes, you can have "many circles" of accountability, Grant said, from the perpetrator, to superiors who may have ordered the crime, or failed to exercise control over soldiers involved.

- Top-level liability -

"The levels go all the way up to the top," he said.

In cases where evidence points to top-level criminal liability, the main challenge is "getting access to the suspects," Grant said.

If the Ukraine investigations "point to criminal responsibility of Putin, you would need to put your hands on the person."

"That's not going to be something easy," he said, but "it is possible."

Importantly, there is no statute of limitation for war crimes.

Those involved could be held accountable even decades after the fact, as with former concentration camp guards and officials still being put on trial for crimes committed during World War II.

Grant said for Ukraine, even lower-level commanders and civilian authorities "could be liable for crimes committed for a long time to come."

"Putin is 69," he pointed out. "That leaves a little bit of room, but there are others."

"There are probably hundreds of people in the security apparatus who could at some point be held accountable, not even talking about the field soldiers."

S.Weaver--TFWP