The Fort Worth Press - Swiss neutrality under fire over Ukraine war

USD -
AED 3.672895
AFN 74.500248
ALL 95.168058
AMD 395.960606
ANG 1.804365
AOA 913.489344
ARS 1053.829278
AUD 1.595405
AWG 1.8025
AZN 1.701546
BAM 1.880134
BBD 2.021408
BDT 121.64442
BGN 1.88753
BHD 0.37683
BIF 2963.475653
BMD 1
BND 1.350521
BOB 6.918562
BRL 5.815496
BSD 1.001187
BTN 87.539113
BWP 13.895498
BYN 3.276408
BYR 19600
BZD 2.011026
CAD 1.435435
CDF 2855.000205
CHF 0.905017
CLF 0.025304
CLP 970.989604
CNY 7.2901
CNH 7.29388
COP 4176.58
CRC 508.043623
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 105.998049
CZK 24.243976
DJF 178.281496
DKK 7.200402
DOP 61.888077
DZD 135.515187
EGP 50.315004
ERN 15
ETB 126.299323
EUR 0.96526
FJD 2.3133
FKP 0.823587
GBP 0.807995
GEL 2.793899
GGP 0.823587
GHS 15.418483
GIP 0.823587
GMD 71.999884
GNF 8655.486823
GTQ 7.74041
GYD 209.460271
HKD 7.78622
HNL 25.650322
HRK 7.379548
HTG 130.957016
HUF 391.843947
IDR 16355
ILS 3.55224
IMP 0.823587
INR 87.58755
IQD 1311.51796
IRR 42099.999771
ISK 141.497735
JEP 0.823587
JMD 158.095851
JOD 0.7094
JPY 152.331495
KES 129.102503
KGS 87.449697
KHR 4017.000126
KMF 472.949688
KPW 900.000111
KRW 1450.669957
KWD 0.30854
KYD 0.834315
KZT 517.536566
LAK 21770.832833
LBP 89655.036505
LKR 298.90074
LRD 199.228081
LSL 18.642256
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.917978
MAD 10.021005
MDL 18.741559
MGA 4698.999981
MKD 59.354036
MMK 3247.960992
MNT 3398.000107
MOP 8.031089
MRU 39.915791
MUR 46.669793
MVR 15.409606
MWK 1736.01665
MXN 20.61917
MYR 4.435003
MZN 63.910213
NAD 18.642256
NGN 1502.501249
NIO 36.759615
NOK 11.245397
NPR 140.061427
NZD 1.766305
OMR 0.385027
PAB 1.001206
PEN 3.716498
PGK 4.004499
PHP 58.107977
PKR 278.950223
PLN 4.059165
PYG 7888.374597
QAR 3.650547
RON 4.803402
RSD 113.027005
RUB 97.073583
RWF 1396
SAR 3.750501
SBD 8.43942
SCR 14.387108
SDG 600.990182
SEK 10.913964
SGD 1.353404
SHP 0.823587
SLE 22.894998
SLL 20969.49992
SOS 572.167401
SRD 35.104943
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.760352
SYP 13001.999985
SZL 18.631791
THB 33.775504
TJS 10.927906
TMT 3.51
TND 3.178498
TOP 2.342102
TRY 35.892402
TTD 6.78103
TWD 32.852802
TZS 2543.778995
UAH 41.670936
UGX 3684.708891
UYU 43.566241
UZS 13000.000216
VES 59.381045
VND 25270
VUV 118.722008
WST 2.800827
XAF 630.573273
XAG 0.03117
XAU 0.000349
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.767889
XOF 629.507636
XPF 114.645518
YER 248.950045
ZAR 18.58365
ZMK 9001.199354
ZMW 28.057274
ZWL 321.999592
  • RYCEF

    -0.0600

    7.44

    -0.81%

  • GSK

    -0.3300

    37.37

    -0.88%

  • RELX

    -0.4940

    50.276

    -0.98%

  • RIO

    1.2700

    62.64

    +2.03%

  • BCC

    1.0700

    125.82

    +0.85%

  • VOD

    0.1550

    8.425

    +1.84%

  • RBGPF

    -0.7000

    65.3

    -1.07%

  • CMSC

    0.0000

    23.5

    0%

  • BCE

    -0.7300

    24.17

    -3.02%

  • NGG

    -0.5400

    62.13

    -0.87%

  • AZN

    3.0750

    74.01

    +4.15%

  • CMSD

    0.0080

    23.828

    +0.03%

  • SCS

    -0.0300

    11.53

    -0.26%

  • BTI

    0.1600

    41.26

    +0.39%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    12.83

    0%

  • BP

    0.4850

    32.155

    +1.51%

Swiss neutrality under fire over Ukraine war
Swiss neutrality under fire over Ukraine war

Swiss neutrality under fire over Ukraine war

Russia's invasion of Ukraine has pushed Switzerland to shed taboos, with calls for rearmament and unprecedented sanctions putting its deeply engrained neutrality to the test of a war in Europe.

Text size:

Critics in Switzerland have warned that government moves could "torpedo" one of the wealthy Alpine nation's key principles, dictating no involvement in conflicts between other states.

After Russian troops entered Ukraine on February 24, Bern cited that neutrality when it initially refrained from jumping onboard with biting sanctions imposed by the European Union.

But four days later, the government buckled to international pressure and imposed all the EU sanctions, prompting criticism it was throwing neutrality to the wind.

The move, which the government insisted was "compatible" with its neutrality, was widely welcomed on the international stage.

It even earned a mention in US President Joe Biden's State of the Union address, when he hailed that "even Switzerland" was with those striving to hold Moscow accountable for its aggression.

But at home, it sparked outrage from the far right, which demands total neutrality, both on military and political.

The largest party, the populist right-wing Swiss People's Party (SVP), has threatened to push the issue to a referendum, as part of the country's direct democracy system.

The SVP has also lashed out at Bern's efforts to gain a non-permanent seat on the UN Security Council, warning this would "torpedo" the country's neutrality.

The government has argued that if it is granted the seat in June elections, it can simply abstain on issues that cast doubt on its neutrality.

- "Schizophrenia" -

The Swiss candidacy has meanwhile received backing from most lawmakers, and all other parties have voiced support for the sanctions.

"This marks a move towards a more active political neutrality," Swiss-American political scientist Daniel Warner told AFP.

Former president Micheline Calmy-Rey has chimed in, insisting that while militarily neutral, Switzerland is "free to defend its interests by adapting its foreign policy, and is free to impose sanctions".

Switzerland distinguishes between the law of neutrality -- which was codified in The Hague Conventions of 1907 and which imposes non-participation in international armed conflict -- and the policy of neutrality.

The latter is not governed by law, and its implementation "is determined according to the international context of the moment", the government explains on its website.

The combination can make for complex policy decisions.

At times it tilts towards "schizophrenia", Warner said.

He pointed to how Switzerland followed the EU sanctions against Moscow, but refused to participate in a widely-backed boycott at the UN of Russia's chief diplomat Sergei Lavrov.

This is not the first time Swiss neutrality has been questioned.

"During the Cold War, one could say it was a completely Atlanticist neutrality," Stephanie Roulin, a Fribourg University historian, told AFP.

- 'Very malleable' neutrality -

The Swiss, she said, had for instance given in to "American pressure" and "secretly committed to respect the economic embargo against the Eastern bloc countries", agreed in the Hotz-Linder Accord of 1951.

"Swiss neutrality was very malleable and was applied according to Switzerland's economic and financial interests," agreed historian Hans-Ulrich Jost, honorary professor at Lausanne University.

He pointed out that Switzerland's refusal to join the international boycott of South Africa against the racist apartheid system "allowed it to become an intermediary in the gold trade".

Many observers also suggest Switzerland violated the principle of neutrality during World War II, with massive weapon exports to the Axis powers.

The conflict in Ukraine has also rattled Swiss defence policies, and put previously taboo topics on the table.

Some have gone so far as to evoke a rapprochement with NATO or the EU's defence cooperation, while calls to boost defence spending have multiplied.

Swiss army chief Thomas Sussli stressed in a recent interview with the Tribune de Geneve daily that if Switzerland needs to defend itself, "neutrality will be null and void".

In such a case, he said, "We would need to ally ourselves with other states, and possibly also with NATO."

S.Jordan--TFWP