The Fort Worth Press - US experts: militarily, the Russian invasion is a disaster so far

USD -
AED 3.672987
AFN 70.500239
ALL 93.595037
AMD 388.780375
ANG 1.801862
AOA 856.498055
ARS 902.491597
AUD 1.511603
AWG 1.8025
AZN 1.700338
BAM 1.82576
BBD 2.018717
BDT 117.482322
BGN 1.82179
BHD 0.376951
BIF 2880
BMD 1
BND 1.35275
BOB 6.908913
BRL 5.423015
BSD 0.99979
BTN 83.513734
BWP 13.565777
BYN 3.271955
BYR 19600
BZD 2.015263
CAD 1.371285
CDF 2849.999781
CHF 0.88838
CLF 0.033577
CLP 926.489881
CNY 7.255977
CNH 7.27006
COP 4130.63
CRC 525.379822
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 103.224975
CZK 23.019687
DJF 177.720074
DKK 6.946297
DOP 59.302368
DZD 134.822871
EGP 47.709803
ERN 15
ETB 57.508119
EUR 0.93115
FJD 2.24275
FKP 0.784602
GBP 0.78665
GEL 2.864996
GGP 0.784602
GHS 15.050372
GIP 0.784602
GMD 67.775008
GNF 8594.999727
GTQ 7.768676
GYD 209.147337
HKD 7.81049
HNL 24.809895
HRK 7.018438
HTG 132.623865
HUF 368.537028
IDR 16466.5
ILS 3.72354
IMP 0.784602
INR 83.50635
IQD 1310
IRR 42098.4977
ISK 139.219912
JEP 0.784602
JMD 155.774931
JOD 0.708899
JPY 157.608504
KES 128.501057
KGS 87.859904
KHR 4115.000025
KMF 458.999628
KPW 900.000131
KRW 1379.11974
KWD 0.306702
KYD 0.833158
KZT 453.602184
LAK 21937.501116
LBP 89549.999795
LKR 303.717706
LRD 194.149745
LSL 18.260309
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.854964
MAD 9.997498
MDL 17.851525
MGA 4474.999499
MKD 57.317249
MMK 2093.723681
MNT 3450.000098
MOP 8.042003
MRU 39.450244
MUR 47.107134
MVR 15.404244
MWK 1733.000227
MXN 18.538303
MYR 4.717499
MZN 63.69504
NAD 18.260293
NGN 1495.000379
NIO 36.830038
NOK 10.654397
NPR 133.621788
NZD 1.630455
OMR 0.384936
PAB 0.99979
PEN 3.792962
PGK 3.845002
PHP 58.675005
PKR 278.624961
PLN 4.047491
PYG 7529.697309
QAR 3.64075
RON 4.633902
RSD 109.013
RUB 88.724219
RWF 1308
SAR 3.75206
SBD 8.447127
SCR 13.913018
SDG 586.000399
SEK 10.473525
SGD 1.351498
SHP 1.26345
SLE 22.847303
SLL 20969.501917
SOS 571.000488
SRD 31.367499
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.747929
SYP 2512.530426
SZL 18.259969
THB 36.809742
TJS 10.761656
TMT 3.51
TND 3.131497
TOP 2.360897
TRY 32.823897
TTD 6.795024
TWD 32.317948
TZS 2604.999653
UAH 40.641789
UGX 3704.170459
UYU 39.291465
UZS 12649.999779
VEF 3622552.534434
VES 36.372187
VND 25450
VUV 118.721975
WST 2.800615
XAF 612.342878
XAG 0.033879
XAU 0.000431
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.758757
XOF 612.504821
XPF 110.925026
YER 250.349769
ZAR 18.23835
ZMK 9001.201876
ZMW 25.819972
ZWL 321.999592
  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    56.5

    0%

  • CMSC

    -0.1100

    24.43

    -0.45%

  • VOD

    0.1200

    8.86

    +1.35%

  • RYCEF

    0.0200

    5.83

    +0.34%

  • BCC

    0.2500

    126.85

    +0.2%

  • GSK

    0.0100

    40.66

    +0.02%

  • CMSD

    -0.0600

    24.3

    -0.25%

  • SCS

    0.1000

    12.5

    +0.8%

  • RELX

    0.2600

    45.48

    +0.57%

  • NGG

    -0.7500

    55.8

    -1.34%

  • RIO

    -0.5200

    65.99

    -0.79%

  • JRI

    0.1600

    12.05

    +1.33%

  • BCE

    -0.2400

    32.64

    -0.74%

  • BTI

    0.3100

    30.94

    +1%

  • AZN

    -0.2800

    79.31

    -0.35%

  • BP

    0.2200

    35.11

    +0.63%

US experts: militarily, the Russian invasion is a disaster so far
US experts: militarily, the Russian invasion is a disaster so far

US experts: militarily, the Russian invasion is a disaster so far

The Russian military's initial invasion of Ukraine has been a surprising strategic and tactical blunder marked by food and fuel shortages, abandoned armored vehicles, aircraft losses and troop deaths, US experts say.

Text size:

But the failures of the first days, including vastly underestimating the Ukrainians' willingness to fight back, could lead to a frustrated Moscow deciding to unleash all its power and indiscriminately destroying large swathes of Ukraine, they said.

US specialists who study the Russian military say they have been astonished by the mismanagement of the campaign, which has seen invading columns stalled, apparently hundreds of Russian armored vehicles lost, and the Ukrainians preventing the Kremlin's air force from controlling the skies.

"If you were going to screw it up two or three weeks in, I might understand it," said Scott Boston, a senior defense analyst at the Rand Corp. think tank.

"But if you, like, tripped over the doorframe on the way into the house, you have another issue," he said.

- 'Disaster, through and through' -

The Pentagon and private sector experts expected Russian President Vladimir Putin's army to quickly destroy Ukraine's ability to fight back, undermining its command and control of the 200,000-strong Ukraine military, wrecking its missile defenses and destroying Kyiv's air force.

None of that has happened in the first six days. And, although there are no reliable estimates of the dead, injured and captured Russian troops, the numbers appear to be much higher than what would have been expected in a well-managed invasion.

"This is a colossal intelligence failure that vastly underestimated Ukrainian resistance, and military execution has been terrible," Michael Vickers, former US Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence, said this week at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

"His main attack has been underweighted. It's been piecemeal. His reconnaissance elements have been captured, columns have been destroyed," he said.

"It's just a disaster, through and through."

- Aircraft losses -

An assessment by military experts of the Atlantic Council's Scowcroft Center pointed to the crucial failure of the Russians to quickly seize and hold an airport just outside Kyiv.

The fight over the airport left it likely too damaged to use as planned to invade Kyiv, they said.

Moreover, they said, "Russian aircraft and helicopter losses have been surprisingly high and unsustainable," because they did not destroy the Ukrainians' air defenses.

Also surprising was the limited or ineffective deployment of electronic warfare weapons, which most analysts expected would have a significant role in attacking the Ukrainians' ability to communicate.

"Were the Russians able to cut off Ukrainian military leaders from those they are commanding ... Ukrainian air and air-defense forces would have been forced to fight in an uncoordinated fashion, making them less lethal and more susceptible to attack," the Scowcroft Center report said.

Boston pointed out that the Ukrainians have continued to use their Turkish-made Bayraktar drones to destroy Russian armor.

"If they got hit with the Turkish drones once or twice, okay," he said.

"If they got hit more than once or twice, something's wrong on the Russian side."

- Food shortages -

Pentagon spokesman John Kirby said that the Russians appeared to not coordinate well their sizable and diverse capabilities, or manage the logistics for the invasion.

"We're seeing indications here early on that though they have sophisticated combined arms capabilities, that they're not being necessarily fully integrated," he said.

Equally surprising was their logistics shortcomings.

"We're seeing vehicles abandoned. We're seeing sustainment problems not just in fuel but in food," he said Wednesday.

Boston, who has taken part in high-level war games focused on the Russian force, said there are signs they much of the force is young, undertrained for this kind of conflict, and probably unaware they were even going to war.

He said it appeared, too, that the troops on the ground had no sense of what they were trying to do in invading Ukraine, with its longstanding ties to Russia.

"If you don't know what's going on ... you can't adapt," he said.

None of the experts count the Russians out. The Russian force's advance has stalled, but that could allow it to resolve its logistical problems, noted Kirby.

And to the contrary, they expect Putin's frustration over the first days could lead to his unleashing the full force of his artillery, missiles and air power on the Ukrainian population with devastating effect.

"Russia still holds the overwhelming combat power advantages that will eventually grind down Ukrainian forces as the war continues," said the Scowcroft Center analysis.

P.Navarro--TFWP