The Fort Worth Press - Hong Kong activists fade from view as national security case drags

USD -
AED 3.672504
AFN 73.671318
ALL 95.840841
AMD 404.387377
ANG 1.800674
AOA 831.503981
ARS 837.498454
AUD 1.525553
AWG 1.8
AZN 1.70397
BAM 1.804826
BBD 2.017349
BDT 109.657177
BGN 1.804826
BHD 0.376505
BIF 2854.150325
BMD 1
BND 1.343423
BOB 6.903521
BRL 4.957689
BSD 0.999123
BTN 83.045541
BWP 13.79043
BYN 3.26969
BYR 19600
BZD 2.013934
CAD 1.34865
CDF 2765.000362
CHF 0.88059
CLF 0.035523
CLP 978.692382
CNY 7.195404
COP 3925.160338
CRC 514.09588
CUC 1
CUP 26.5
CVE 101.753334
CZK 23.428104
DJF 177.917224
DKK 6.88885
DOP 58.708993
DZD 134.49804
EGP 30.846676
ERN 15
ETB 56.665529
EUR 0.92305
FJD 2.235204
FKP 0.788863
GBP 0.788706
GEL 2.650391
GGP 0.788863
GHS 12.539104
GIP 0.788863
GMD 67.27504
GNF 8587.643612
GTQ 7.807872
GYD 209.034282
HKD 7.82285
HNL 24.669404
HRK 7.030095
HTG 132.505883
HUF 359.530388
IDR 15594.15
ILS 3.63115
IMP 0.788863
INR 82.88205
IQD 1308.817423
IRR 42032.503818
ISK 137.803816
JEP 0.788863
JMD 156.268168
JOD 0.70904
JPY 150.48504
KES 143.376551
KGS 89.430385
KHR 4071.425276
KMF 454.950384
KPW 899.999196
KRW 1331.00035
KWD 0.30774
KYD 0.832649
KZT 450.615974
LAK 20847.136991
LBP 89392.977437
LKR 310.644581
LRD 190.650382
LSL 19.190382
LTL 2.95274
LVL 0.60489
LYD 4.826282
MAD 10.030637
MDL 17.88954
MGA 4532.828865
MKD 56.863378
MMK 2098.186684
MNT 3406.327173
MOP 8.051216
MRU 39.750379
MUR 45.620379
MVR 15.403741
MWK 1681.908365
MXN 17.116204
MYR 4.777504
MZN 63.503732
NAD 19.190377
NGN 1607.000344
NIO 36.773866
NOK 10.600505
NPR 132.87316
NZD 1.613684
OMR 0.38496
PAB 0.999123
PEN 3.786924
PGK 3.807502
PHP 55.935039
PKR 279.13007
PLN 3.979237
PYG 7273.566188
QAR 3.640504
RON 4.597904
RSD 108.141928
RUB 93.055038
RWF 1274.304434
SAR 3.750554
SBD 8.500465
SCR 13.403497
SDG 601.00034
SEK 10.292915
SGD 1.343038
SHP 1.26625
SLE 22.483622
SLL 19750.000338
SOS 571.503664
SRD 35.701038
STD 20697.981008
SVC 8.742675
SYP 13001.869854
SZL 19.261754
THB 35.930369
TJS 10.940433
TMT 3.51
TND 3.123504
TOP 2.360304
TRY 30.818685
TTD 6.790938
TWD 31.617038
TZS 2547.778342
UAH 38.242329
UGX 3931.158584
UYU 39.080884
UZS 12479.121488
VEF 3618584.714698
VES 36.186223
VND 24640
VUV 120.023184
WST 2.739916
XAF 605.321829
XAG 0.043588
XAU 0.000491
XCD 2.70255
XDR 0.75421
XOF 605.321829
XPF 110.380364
YER 250.350363
ZAR 19.25804
ZMK 9001.203589
ZMW 22.954829
ZWL 321.999592
  • SLAC

    -0.0050

    10.305

    -0.05%

  • SCS

    0.1000

    12.8

    +0.78%

  • BP

    -0.1100

    35.38

    -0.31%

  • CMSC

    0.0200

    24.8

    +0.08%

  • BTI

    0.0300

    30.5

    +0.1%

  • NGG

    0.6100

    66.64

    +0.92%

  • RBGPF

    0.3360

    72.822

    +0.46%

  • RIO

    0.2900

    65.98

    +0.44%

  • CMSD

    0.0500

    24.81

    +0.2%

  • AZN

    1.7000

    65.83

    +2.58%

  • GSK

    0.0600

    42.22

    +0.14%

  • RELX

    0.0900

    44.44

    +0.2%

  • BCE

    -0.0100

    37.6

    -0.03%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0300

    4.45

    -0.67%

  • VOD

    0.0700

    8.47

    +0.83%

  • BCC

    2.8800

    129.42

    +2.23%

  • JRI

    0.0425

    11.53

    +0.37%

Hong Kong activists fade from view as national security case drags
Hong Kong activists fade from view as national security case drags

Hong Kong activists fade from view as national security case drags

Hong Kong's most prominent democracy activists have disappeared from view as their prosecution under a security law drags into its second year, with lawyers and family members warning the defendants are losing faith in the courts.

Text size:

The 47 activists make up a swathe of the city's depleted democracy movement, from veteran former lawmakers to young firebrands and community organisers as well as academics and unionists.

Charged with subversion, the majority have been held in custody for more than a year and the few granted bail must adhere to strict speech curbs.

Most of what has occurred during pre-trial hearings is blanketed by reporting restrictions, even though the defendants want them lifted. And their trial is not expected to begin until at least 2023.

"The prosecution and the court are making the defendants invisible in plain sight," legal scholar Eric Lai of Georgetown University told AFP.

Using the national security law Beijing imposed in 2020 following huge democracy protests, authorities targeted the activists for organising an unofficial poll to choose opposition candidates.

Some observers have voiced alarm about how lengthy pre-trial proceedings under the law have generated precedent-setting decisions without public scrutiny.

The hearings, Lai said, have produced "very substantial evaluations that are rarely seen in ordinary criminal cases" including detailed discussions over the security law's stricter bail terms, the admissibility of evidence as well as shifting prosecution charges.

"(Court) procedures should be more open and transparent so the public can see how the court handled the cases and what it did to protect the integrity of trial."

- Changing legal landscape -

Hong Kong faces scrutiny over whether its internationally respected common law legal system can be maintained as China cracks down on dissent with the security law, which has ensnared some 170 people.

Last month, two of Britain's most senior judges pulled out of sitting on Hong Kong's top court citing the law's impact on freedoms, though nine other foreign judges confirmed they would stay.

The prosecution of the 47 activists is seen as a legal litmus test.

While Hong Kong allows the public to attend pre-trial hearings, reporting is largely limited to names, hearing dates and what a judge rules –- unless that judge lifts restrictions.

The rules are in place to protect a defendant from potential prejudice, especially if a jury may be involved in their trial.

But so far, all national security cases to reach trial stage have been heard by handpicked judges, not juries.

The 47 activists want the reporting restrictions lifted but their requests have been opposed by the prosecution and denied by the courts.

Independent legal scholar Wong Kai-yeung said it was unusual for judges both in Hong Kong and under the English common law to deny such requests.

"Here it was they, the defendants to be put on trial, who actively sought publicity of the proceedings," he told AFP.

"It is their trial. They have the autonomy to make the informed decision to not accept arrangements brought in in the name of their protection."

- 'Frustrated and defeated' -

Those facing trial are in custody or barred from speaking to the press as part of their bail conditions.

But four barristers with knowledge of the proceedings told AFP that defendants were growing exasperated, believing prosecutors have filed vague charges and are dragging their feet, knowing their actions will not face public scrutiny or backlash.

All requested anonymity to speak freely.

"Some defendants feel they are being played by the court, the prosecution and the whole procedure," said one barrister. "They think it's a sham."

"There has been general distrust of the impartiality of the proceedings," another said. "It's fair to say some defendants do not believe they will get a fair trial in this case."

The barristers themselves also described a sense of frustration with proceedings -– two accused prosecutors of "moving the goalposts" by failing to disclose key evidence and frequently changing the charges.

Hong Kong's Department of Justice said it took "strong exception" to such criticisms.

"Any allegation that the prosecution is 'taking advantage' of the reporting restrictions is based on a misconception of the rationale underlying such restrictions, if not based on malice," it said.

The judiciary said it would not comment on individual cases.

Chan Po-ying, an activist and the wife of former lawmaker Leung Kwok-hung, said the media blackout had "dialled up the pressure" on defendants.

"When public attention starts to wane, it could make them feel frustrated and defeated."

Emilia Wong, the partner of detained activist Ventus Lau, said the defendants were "exhausted" and feeling silenced.

"This is what authorities want -- to minimise the defendants' influence."

S.Palmer--TFWP